The Evolution of Dental Zirconia
A journey from antiquity to modern excellence
Jack Marrano, CDT
When it comes to restorative materials, few have made as significant an impact on dentistry as zirconia. Known for its exceptional strength, biocompatibility, and esthetic qualities, zirconia has revolutionized the placement of indirect dental restorations. Understanding the history of zirconia and the advancements that have been made in its evolution are key to appropriately using the material in its cutting-edge applications in modern dentistry.
Origins of Zirconia
The story of zirconia begins with zirconium (Zr), the element from which it is derived. Zirconium is a lustrous, grayish-white metal that is highly resistant to corrosion. The mineral zircon (ZrSiO4), from which zirconium is extracted, has been appreciated since antiquity. Zircon crystals, which are often found in sand and sedimentary deposits, have been used as gemstones for thousands of years. The oldest known zircons were discovered in Australia, and they date back more than 4.4 billion years, making them some of the oldest rock fragments on Earth. This can largely be attributed to their durability and chemical resistance.1
Despite the ancient origins of zircon, the use of zirconium in its metallic and oxidized forms did not emerge until much later. The element itself was isolated in 1824 by the Swedish chemist Jöns Jacob Berzelius.2 However, its potential applications in various fields, including dentistry, were not realized until the 20th century.
Early Dental Applications
The introduction of zirconia into dentistry was driven by the need for esthetic materials that could withstand the harsh conditions of the oral environment. Traditional dental materials, such as amalgam and gold, were durable but lacked the esthetic qualities desired by patients, and although porcelain offered superior esthetics, it was prone to chipping and fracture. The quest for a material that combined strength, durability, and esthetics led researchers to explore zirconia. In the late 20th century, advancements in material science and engineering paved the way for the development of dental-grade zirconia. This material, known as zirconium dioxide (ZrO2), is a ceramic that exhibits remarkable properties, including high fracture toughness, excellent wear resistance, and biocompatibility. Unfortunately, pure zirconium dioxide is unstable and exhibits structural changes that weaken it and limit its use in dentistry.
The Advent of Yttria-Stabilized Zirconia
One of the critical breakthroughs in the use of zirconia in dentistry was the development of yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystal (Y-TZP). Y-TZP is a form of zirconia that is stabilized with yttrium oxide, which enhances its mechanical properties and prevents the phase transformation that can lead to cracking. Y-TZP zirconia emerged as a game-changer in the early 2000s. It offered a combination of strength and translucency that made it ideal for dental restorations (Figure 1 through Figure 3). Unlike traditional ceramics, Y-TZP zirconia could withstand the significant forces exerted during chewing and grinding, permitting it to be used for both anterior and posterior restorations.3,4
Modern Advancements in Zirconia Technology
The evolution of dental zirconia did not stop with the development of Y-TZP. During the past 2 decades, ongoing research and technological advancements have led to the development of new generations of zirconia with improved properties.
Multilayered Zirconia
One of the most notable advancements has been the creation of multilayered zirconia. Traditional monolithic zirconia restorations often required extensive shading and staining to achieve a natural appearance. However, multilayered zirconia incorporates different layers of varying translucency and color, which mimics the gradient found in natural teeth. This innovation has significantly enhanced the esthetic appeal of zirconia restorations, allowing for more lifelike dental prostheses.
Multilayered zirconia restorations are designed to address the demand for both functionality and esthetics. By incorporating multiple layers, these restorations can achieve a seamless transition from the more opaque core to the translucent enamel-like surface. This not only improves their overall appearance but also reduces the need for additional veneering porcelain, which can be susceptible to chipping and wear.
High-Translucency Zirconia
Another significant development has been the evolution of high-translucency zirconia.5 Although early zirconia materials were strong, they were relatively opaque when compared with natural teeth. High-translucency zirconia addresses this issue by offering improved light transmission properties that enable it to closely resemble the translucency and brightness of natural enamel. This advancement has made zirconia a preferred choice for anterior restorations where esthetics are paramount.
The production of high-translucency zirconia is achieved through meticulous control of the material's microstructure and the incorporation of specific dopants. These modifications enhance the material's ability to transmit light in various ways, creating a more lifelike appearance. With high-translucency zirconia, dental professionals can now provide patients with zirconia restorations that blend seamlessly with their natural teeth, even in the highly visible areas in the front of the mouth.
Benefits of CAD/CAM Technology
The integration of computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing (CAD/CAM) technology has also revolutionized the fabrication of zirconia restorations. CAD/CAM technology has streamlined workflows in both dental laboratories and clinics. In these workflows, digital impressions have eliminated the need for traditional impression materials, which can be uncomfortable for patients and prone to inaccuracy. The digital files are used to design highly accurate restorations, which are then milled from zirconia blocks or discs using high-precision milling machines. This technology, which process ensures a high level of accuracy and reduces the risk of human error, not only enhances the precision and fit of restorations but also reduces the time required for production, benefiting both dentists and patients.
Clinical Applications of Zirconia
The versatility of zirconia has led to its widespread adoption in various clinical applications within dentistry.6
Crowns and Bridges
Crowns and bridges are among the most common applications for zirconia (Figure 4 and Figure 5). Thanks to zirconia's strength and durability, zirconia restorations can withstand the forces of mastication, which makes them ideal for posterior teeth. And thanks to the esthetic qualities of high-translucency zirconia, zirconia restorations are also suitable for anterior teeth, providing a natural and pleasing appearance.
The ability to produce lifelike monolithic zirconia restorations-ones made entirely from zirconia without a veneering layer-has further enhanced the popularity of the material. Monolithic zirconia restorations reduce the risk of chipping and fracture associated with layered ceramics. In addition, advancements in staining and glazing techniques have allowed dental professionals to achieve highly esthetic results with monolithic zirconia that more closely match the appearance of natural teeth.
Implant Abutments
Zirconia is also used in the fabrication of dental implants and implant abutments.7 Zirconia abutments are highly biocompatible, and their esthetics are excellent because their tooth-colored appearance blends seamlessly with the surrounding tissue. Zirconia's biocompatibility minimizes the risk of peri-implantitis, which is a common concern with metal abutments. Moreover, zirconia's resistance to corrosion and plaque accumulation contributes to the long-term success of implant-supported restorations. Zirconia abutments are particularly advantageous in the esthetic zone where the appearance of restorations is critical. Their color prevents the appearance of the grayish tint that can often be seen through the gingiva when metal abutments are used, especially in patients with thin gingival biotypes.
Full-Arch Prostheses
For patients who require full-arch restorations, zirconia can provide a reliable and esthetically pleasing solution. Zirconia-based prostheses can be designed to replace an entire arch of teeth, offering strength and stability while maintaining a natural appearance (Figure 6 and Figure 7). This application is particularly beneficial for patients with significant tooth loss or those seeking a durable alternative to removable dentures. Implant-supported, full-arch zirconia prostheses provide patients with a fixed, nonremovable solution that mimics the function and appearance of natural teeth. These restorations can significantly improve quality of life for patients, restoring their ability to chew, speak, and smile confidently. The durability of zirconia ensures that these restorations can withstand the rigors of daily life and provide long-term satisfaction.
Challenges and Future Directions
Although zirconia has transformed modern dentistry, its use is not without challenges. One of the primary concerns is the potential for wear on opposing natural teeth, particularly with harder, more abrasive zirconia materials.8 Ongoing research aims to address this issue by developing zirconia formulations with optimized surface properties that minimize wear and improve patient outcomes. In other efforts to mitigate zirconia's wear on opposing dentition, researchers are exploring various surface treatments and polishing techniques. Highly polished zirconia surfaces have been shown to significantly reduce the abrasive potential of the material.
Another challenge is ensuring the long-term stability of zirconia restorations. Although zirconia is highly resistant to fracture, improper handling during fabrication or placement can lead to microcracks and compromised integrity. Advances in processing techniques and the use of protective coatings are being explored to further enhance the longevity of zirconia restorations.
To address these and other challenges associated with zirconia, education and training for dental professionals is crucial. Proper handling of zirconia during the processes of fabrication and placement can prevent the introduction of defects that may compromise the integrity of restorations. Continuing education and professional development and adherence to best practices ensure that zirconia restorations perform optimally over the long term.
Looking ahead, the future of dental zirconia is promising. Innovations in material science, such as the development of hybrid zirconia-composite materials, hold the potential for even greater advancements. These materials aim to combine the best qualities of zirconia and composite resins, offering enhanced strength, flexibility, and esthetics. Hybrid zirconia-composite materials seek to leverage the translucency and esthetic appeal of composite resins while maintaining the strength and durability of zirconia. This approach could result in restorations that are even more lifelike and durable, expanding the range of clinical applications for zirconia-based materials.
Conclusion
The journey of dental zirconia from its ancient origins to its current status as a premier dental material is a testament to the power of scientific innovation and technological advancement. Its remarkable evolution is a shining example of how science and technology can come together to create materials that not only meet but also exceed the demands of modern dentistry. Today, zirconia stands at the forefront of indirect restorative materials. In the hands of skilled practitioners, zirconia has the potential to transform smiles, improve oral health, and enhance quality of life for countless individuals around the world. As research and development continue to push the boundaries of what is possible, the future of dental zirconia promises to bring even more remarkable breakthroughs that will ultimately benefit patients and dental professionals alike.
References
1. Oskin B. Confirmed: oldest fragment of early earth is 4.4 billion years old. Live Science website. https://www.livescience.com/43584-earth-oldest-rock-jack-hills-zircon.html. Published February 24, 2014. Accessed July 3, 2024.
2. Lide DR, ed. CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics. New York, NY: CRC Press; 2007:42.
3. Chen YW, Moussi J, Drury JL, Wataha JC. Zirconia in biomedical applications. Expert Rev Med Devices. 2016;13(10);945-963.
4. Kelly JR, Denry I. Stabilized zirconia as a structural ceramic: an overview. Dent Mater. 2008;24(3):289-298.
5. Zhang Y. Making yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia translucent. Dent Mater. 2014;30(10):1195-1203.
6. Denry I, Kelly JR. State of the art of zirconia for dental applications. Dent Mater. 2008;24(3):299-307.
7. Apratim A, Eachempati P, Salian K, et al. Zirconia in dental implantology: a review. J Int Soc Prev Community Dent. 2015;5(3):147-156.
8. Passos SP, Torrealba Y, Major P, et al. In vitro wear behavior of zirconia opposing enamel: a systematic review. J Prosthodont. 2014;23 (8)593-601.
